Showing posts with label Naga Munchetty. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Naga Munchetty. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 19, 2016

Sunday Morning Live



This morning's Sunday Morning Live was quite engaging and featured admirably well-balanced panels for its three main discussions. 

Its 'big questions' were typical ones for the BBC on a Sunday morning - 'Is America failing its black community?', 'Is Islamic extremism caused by religion of politics?' and 'Are transgender athletes playing fair?' - but, thankfully, there was none of the 'bear pit' atmosphere you usually find on The Big Questions. 

The central discussion - the one on Islamic extremism and the Iraq War - featured Douglas Murray, Lola Adesioye, Charlie Wolf and Remona Aly and there was more agreement between them than might have been expected, despite two being for the Iraq War and two being against it. Quality guests, quality discussion. (Take note, Nicky Campbell!)

Sunday, July 10, 2016

newspapers and Sunday Morning Livenewspapers



This morning's Sunday Morning Live was quite engaging and featured admirably well-balanced panels for its three main discussions. 

Its 'big questions' were typical ones for the BBC on a Sunday morning - 'Is America failing its black community?', 'Is Islamic extremism caused by religion of politics?' and 'Are transgender athletes playing fair?' - but, thankfully, there was none of the 'bear pit' atmosphere you usually find on The Big Questions. 

The central discussion - the one on Islamic extremism and the Iraq War - featured Douglas Murray, Lola Adesioye, Charlie Wolf and Remona Aly and there was more agreement between them than might have been expected, despite two being for the Iraq War and two being against it. Quality guests, quality discussion. (Take note, Nicky Campbell!)

The only hint of BBC bias came in a couple of nervous interventions from presenter Naga Munchetty when either Douglas or Charlie were speaking about specifically Muslim aspects of Islamic extremism:
(interrupting) Let's make clear...let's make clear, picking up on Remona's point, that Muslims are being attacked here. This is not just a Muslim problem. This is not just Muslims attacking. Muslims are being attacked.  
(interrupting) And Remona...and Remona, you would, of course, say these acts are abhorrent and not reflective of the whole Muslim community - a tiny, tiny part who have been effected. But how responsible are our politicians in the UK for firing that up?
Remona ought to have been left to speak for herself (which she did very well) rather than having her interesting and fair-minded points shoehorned or pre-packaged into Naga's nervous BBC 'talking points'. 

The programme, incidentally, ended with a performance to mark the Muslim festival of Eid by a Muslim singer, Saif Adam, who, as Naga put it, has "been reflecting on extremists who use Islam as an excuse for violence". The title of his song was "Not in my name".

Saturday, July 2, 2016

newspapers and Don't worry, be happy!newspapers



BBC Breakfast had Frederika Roberts, a smiling "happiness and resilience expert", on this morning's show to help counter what it clearly thinks in a depressed national mood. 

Naga Munchetty wondered, "With all this uncertainty, how do we put a smile back on our faces?"

Presenter Jon Kay welcomed Frederika by saying, "I think the Wales result last night has put a smile back on people's faces, hasn't it? It's been a heck of a ten days or so, hasn't it, whatever your politics? How do we gee ourselves up?" 

Frederika admitted to "ranting" on social media in recent days, but thinks "in the long run it's probably not a helpful thing to do". 
Frederika Roberts: One of the things - no matter which side of the divide you were on in the past week or so - what has been lovely to see is that amongst all the negativity there's also been amazing reports of people doing random acts of kindness. 
Jon Kay: Yeah. We asked viewers actually to send us in pictures this morning, show us the kind of...the little things that have been a difference, made them smile. 
Naga thanked her for "helping us figure out how to cheer ourselves up".

Whether Naga, Jon and Frederika were worrying about the national mood or just 48% of the national mood is a moot question.